Ref. :  000034694
Date :  2011-09-06
Language :  English
Home Page / The whole website
fr / es / de / po / en

Premature fiscal tightening endangers global recovery

Trade and Development Report Warns of Consequences of Fiscal Tightening: The Best Strategy for Dealing with Public Debt is to Promote Growth


UNCTAD´s Trade and Development Report 2011 (1) (TDR 2011) warns that fiscal tightening only addresses the symptoms of the problem, leaving the basic causes unchanged. Higher public debt ratios are a consequence of the crisis, not its cause. A fiscal policy that supports growth is more likely to reduce fiscal deficit and to curb public debt ratios than a restrictive fiscal policy is.

The Trade and Development Report 2011: Post-Crisis Policy Challenges in the World Economy, released today, argues that a shift from fiscal stimulus towards fiscal tightening is self-defeating, especially in the most developed economies which were severely hit by the financial crisis. In such a situation, a restrictive fiscal policy may reduce GDP growth and fiscal revenues, and is therefore counterproductive in terms of fiscal consolidation.

The TDR 2011 shows that fiscal imbalances were not a driving factor of the crisis, but were, rather, a result of the crisis. Between 2002 and 2007, fiscal balances had improved significantly in most developed and developing economies, as a result of growth in output, lower interest rates, and, in some countries, the price boom in commodities. The crisis caused a significant deterioration in public sector accounts, as automatic stabilizers and fiscal stimulus packages were put in place. In several developed countries, public bailouts of financial institutions accounted for a large portion of the deficit, reflecting a conversion from private into public debt.

As a result, the median public debt-to-GDP ratio in developed countries almost doubled, to more than 60 per cent of GDP, between 2007 and the end of 2010. Economic growth in developing countries, as a group, suffered less impact from the financial crisis, partly thanks to active countercyclical fiscal policies; as a result, fiscal balances improved in 2010 and debt-to-GDP ratios remained in check.

The main argument that is usually advanced in support of fiscal tightening is that it is indispensable in order to restore the confidence of financial markets, which is perceived as being key to economic recovery. But in light of the irresponsible behaviour of many private financial market actors, which has required costly government intervention to prevent the collapse of the financial system, public opinion and policymakers should not trust again those institutions, including rating agencies, to judge what constitutes sound macroeconomic policies and sound management of public finances.

The reduction in growth-promoting fiscal expenditure may lead to a decline in future government revenues that will be larger than the fiscal savings obtained by retrenchment - with negative consequences for long-term fiscal and debt sustainability.

Countries that put fiscal tightening packages in place during the 1990s and 2000s as part of IMF-supported programmes have failed to consider these dynamic effects. In countries where fiscal tightening was expected to reduce the budget deficit and restart growth, deficits actually became worse while GDP growth stalled. In the present situation, the current fiscal tightening policies adopted by some countries are likely to deliver similar negative results.

There is a widespread perception that space for a continuation of fiscal stimuli is already exhausted, especially in developed countries. But fiscal space is not a static variable. An expansionary fiscal policy can have strong effects on demand, increase private-sector incomes, and generate higher fiscal revenues. It is possible to extend the economic impact of fiscal policies by changing the composition of public expenditure or structuring public revenues in a way that maximizes their multiplier effects without necessarily modifying the total amount of expenditure or the fiscal balance.

The TDR 2011 shows that the way the public sector spends and taxes is not neutral. Increases in spending on infrastructure, social transfers, or targeted subsidies for private investors tend to be more effective in stimulating the economy than tax cuts, because they directly lead to job creation, purchases, and demand.

Often, the proceeds of reduced tax payments for higher-income groups are not injected back into the economy. History has shown that if tax cuts are the preferred instrument, cuts for the lower-income groups are more effective in raising demand and national income than tax cuts for higher-income groups. Out of necessity, lower-income groups tend to spend their earnings in the local economy.

The challenge for highly indebted developed countries is how to grow out of debt, with growth-enhancing fiscal, monetary and income policies. GDP growth combined with low interest rates is the best strategy for reducing public debt ratios over time. If these cannot be attained because of an external constraint or outright fiscal insolvency, priority should be given to resolving the balance of payments or restructuring the debt, rather than to introducing austerity measures. Furthermore, developing countries should preserve and enlarge their fiscal space, and conduct countercyclical policies, in order to protect themselves from potential negative external shocks.


1. The Trade and Development Report 2011: Post-crisis policy challenges in the world economy (Sales No. E.11.II.D.3, ISBN-13: 978-92-1-112822-2) may be obtained from United Publications Sales and Marketing Office at the address mentioned below or from United Nations sales agents throughout the world. Price: US$ 55 (50 per cent discount for residents of developing countries, and 75 per cent discount for residents of least developed countries). Customers may send orders or inquiries to the United Publications Sales and Marketing Office, 300 East 42nd Street, 9th Floor, IN-919J New York, NY 10017, United States. Tel.: +1 212 963 8302, fax: +1 212 963 3489, e-mail:,


Contacts :

UNCTAD Communications and Information Unit
T: +41 22 917 5828
T: +41 79 502 43 11

Rate this content
Average of 27 ratings 
Rating 2.22 / 4 MoyenMoyenMoyenMoyen
Same author:
 flecheLe développement économique en Afrique - Rapport 2018
 flecheWake up before it is too late: Make agriculture truly sustainable now for food security in a changing climate
 flecheTrade and Development Report, 2013
 flecheWorld Investment Report 2013
 flecheUNCTAD report calls for a shift in foreign investment towards job growth and diversification in poor countries
 flecheUNCTAD/UNDP report says creative industries are stimulating economic recovery
 flecheReport calls for «new international development architecture» to support world´s poorest countries
 flecheTransnational firms can boost contributions towards low-carbon economic growth, report says
 flecheTrade and development Report 2009 - Overview
 flecheThe "Least developed countries Report 2009: The state and development governance"
 flecheManufacturing poverty reduction
 flecheAt inaugural public symposium, “voiceless” have strong words for global financial crisis
 flecheReport "Global Economic Crisis: Systemic failure and multilateral remedies "
 flecheReport on global financial crisis points to "systemic failures", disconnection from "real economy"
 flecheFreight rates begin to fall for world merchand fleet
 flecheReport says strengthening supply capacity is essential for Africa to benefit from trade liberalization
 fleche2008 Statistics Handbook provides background for global economic situation
 flecheCreative Economy Report 2008 - The challenge of assessing the creative economy towards informed policy-making (Overview)
 flecheCreative Economy Report 2008: The challenge of assessing the creative economy towards informed policy-making
 flecheDespite rapid economic growth, number of poor still rising in Least Developed Countries, Report warns
 flecheUNCTAD Secretary-General calls for Accra accord to help make globalization deliver for the world’s poorest
 flecheInformation Economy Report 2007-2008
 flecheCreative industries emerge as key driver of economic growth with trade nearly doubling in decade
 flecheLeaders, improvers and laggards in trade and development performance- Results of UNCTAD new edition of Trade and Development Index (TDI)
 flecheUNCTAD Developing Countries in International Trade 2007: Trade and Development Index
 flecheReliance on domestic financial resources will enable Africa to determine its own development priorities, new UNCTAD report says
 fleche2007 Report on Economic Development in Africa - "Reclaiming policy space: domestic resource mobilization and developmental states"
 flecheThe place of developing countries in globalization
 flecheThe Least Developed Countries Report, 2007 - Knowledge, technical learning and innovation for development
 flecheUNCTAD Handbook of statistics 2006-2007
 flecheStringent intellectual property protection hampers technological progress in the world's poorest countries
 flecheWorld Investment Report 2006 "FDI from Developing and Transition Economies: Implications for Development"
 flecheFirms based in developing countries joining ranks of world's largest transnational corporations
 flecheUNCTAD report calls for multilateral approach to tackle growing trade imbalances
 flecheDeveloping countries need sufficient flexibility in policy making, Report says
 flecheTrade and Development Report, 2006
 flecheThe Least Developed Countries Report, 2006
 flecheAid to least developed countries increases, but is mainly driven by debt relief and emergencies
 flecheDevelopment Must Remain at Heart of Trade Talks
 flecheThe Internet: opportunities, not threats, for developing-countries musicians
 flecheNew UNCTAD study make case for African debt write-off
 flecheTrade and Development Report 2004
 flecheWorld Investment Report 2004
 flecheE-Commerce in Developed Countries Continues on Strong Growth Path
Keywords   go
Translate this page Traduire par Google Translate

Share on Facebook
Partager sur Twitter
Share on Google+Google + Share on LinkedInLinkedIn
Partager sur MessengerMessenger Partager sur BloggerBlogger
Other items
where is published this article: