Ref. :  000009112
Date :  2003-09-21
Language :  English
Home Page / The whole website
fr / es / de / po / en

Key Services Often Fail Poor People - New Report Shows How Governments and Citizens Can Do Better

WASHINGTON, September 21, 2003 — A new World Bank report warns that broad improvements in human welfare will not occur unless poor people receive wider access to affordable, better quality services in health, education, water, sanitation, and electricity. Without such improvements in services, freedom from illness and freedom from illiteracy - two of the most important ways poor people can escape poverty - will remain elusive to many.

The report - World Development Report 2004: Making Services Work for Poor People - says that too often, key services fail poor people - in access, in quantity, in quality. This imperils a set of development targets known as the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) which call for a halving of the global incidence of poverty, and broad improvements in human development by 2015. However, the report provides powerful examples of where services do work, showing how governments and citizens can do better. The report says there have been spectacular successes and miserable failures in the efforts by developing countries to make services work. The main difference between success and failure is the degree to which poor people themselves are involved in determining the quality and the quantity of the services which they receive.

"Too often, services fail poor people. These failures may be less spectacular than financial crises, but their effects are continuing and deep nonetheless," says World Bank President, James D. Wolfensohn."Services work when they include all people, when girls are encouraged to go to school, when pupils and parents participate in the schooling process, when communities take charge of their own sanitation. They work when we take a comprehensive view of development - recognizing that a mother’s education will help her baby’s health, that building a road or a bridge will enable children to go to school."

The report comes at a time when rich countries have pledged to increase foreign aid, and poor countries have pledged to improve their policies and institutions, to try to reach the MDGs. "To accelerate progress in human development, economic growth is of course necessary, but it is not enough," says World Bank Chief Economist and Senior Vice-President for Development Economics, Nicholas Stern. "Mobilizing to reach the 2015 development goals will require both a substantial increase in external resources and more effective use of all resources, internal and external. The report offers a practical framework for using resources more effectively."

How services are failing poor people

Personal accounts from poor people in the new report describe how they receive shoddy services.

In Adaboya, Ghana, "children must walk four kilometers to attend school because, while there is a school building in the village, it sits in disrepair and cannot be used in the rainy season." In Potrero Sula, El Salvador, villagers complain that "the health post here is useless because there is no doctor or nurse, and it is only open two days a week until noon." A common response in a client survey by women who had given birth at rural health centers in the Mutasa district of Zimbabwe is that they were hit by staff during delivery.

Anecdotes like these are supported by accounts from other countries as well. The average poor child in rural Mali has to walk 8 kilometers to primary school. Her counterpart in rural Chad has to walk 23 kilometers to get to a clinic. A billion people worldwide lack access to an improved water source; 2.5 billion lack access to improved sanitation.

Even when poor people have access, the quality of services is distressingly low. In random visits to 200 primary schools in India, investigators found no teaching activity in half of them at the time of visit. Up to 45 percent of teachers in Ethiopia were absent at least one day in the week before a visit - 10 percent of them for three days or more. A survey of primary health care facilities in Bangladesh found the absenteeism rate among doctors to be 74 percent.

"Improving the delivery of key services such as healthcare and education to poor people is critical to accelerate progress in human development, because more public spending by itself will not do it," says Jean-Louis Sarbib, the World Bank’s new Senior Vice-President for Human Development, and former Vice President for the Middle East and North Africa Region of the World. "The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region spends more on public education than any other developing region, and yet it has some of the highest rates of youth illiteracy in the world. A girl in MENA is as likely to be illiterate as a girl in Sub-Saharan Africa, which is a much poorer region."

Services can work for poor people

The report points to several success stories. Indonesia used its oil windfalls to build new schools and hire more teachers, doubling primary enrollment to 90 percent by 1986. The number of children enrolled in primary schools in Uganda increased from 3.6 million to 6.9 million in five years. A program in Mexico that gives cash to poor households if they visited a clinic regularly and their children attended school reduced illness among children by 20 percent, and increased secondary enrollment by 5 percentage points for boys and 8 for girls.

"Services can work when poor people stand at the center of service provision - when they can avoid poor providers, while rewarding good providers with their clientele, and when their voices are heard by politicians - that is, when service providers have incentives to serve the poor," says Shanta Devarajan, Director of the World Development Report 2004 , and Chief Economist of the World Bank’s Human Development Network.

The report documents three ways in which services can be improved:

1. By increasing poor clients’ choice and participation in service delivery, so they can monitor and discipline providers. School voucher schemes - such as a program for poor families in Colombia, or a girls’ scholarship program in Bangladesh (that paid schools based on the number of girls they enrolled) - increase clients’ power over providers, and substantially increased enrollment rates. Community-managed schools in El Salvador, where parents visited schools regularly, lowered teacher absenteeism and raised student test scores.

2. By raising poor citizens’ voice, through the ballot box and making information widely available. Service delivery surveys in Bangalore, India, that showed poor people the quality of the water, health, education and transport services they were receiving compared to neighboring districts, increased demand for better public services, and forced politicians to act.

3. By rewarding the effective and penalizing the ineffective delivery of services to poor people. In the aftermath of a civil war, Cambodia paid primary health providers in two districts based on the health of the households (as measured by independent surveys) in their district. Health indicators, as well as use by the poor, in those districts improved relative to other districts.

Public services versus private - a false argument ?

Providing communities with healthcare, education, and other services has been a contentious issue in many countries, with government services pitted against large-scale privatization.

The report says that while there are frequent problems with public services, it would be wrong to conclude that government should give up and leave everything to the private sector. If individuals are left to their own devices, they will not provide levels of education and health that they collectively want. Not only is this true in theory, but in practice no country has achieved significant improvement in child mortality and primary education without government involvement.

Furthermore, private-sector participation in health, education, and infrastructure is not without problems - especially in reaching poor people. The extreme position that the private sector should do everything is clearly not desirable either.

"Instead of getting caught up in the public versus private services argument, the only

issue that really matters is whether the mechanism that delivers key services strengthens poor people’s ability to monitor and discipline providers, raises their voice in policymaking, and gets them the effective services they need for their families,"
says Ritva Reinikka, the Co-Director of WDR 2004, and Research Manager for Public Services at the World Bank.

The report says that some aid donors take a variant of the "leave-everything-to-the-private sector" position. If government services are performing so badly, donors may ask, why give more aid to those governments?

"That would be equally wrong," says Reinikka. "There is now substantial research showing that aid is productive in countries with good policies and institutions, and those policies and institutions have recently been improving. The reforms detailed in this Report (aimed at recipient countries and aid agencies) can make aid even more productive."

When policies and institutions are improving, the report argues, aid should increase, not decrease, to realize the mutually-shared objective of poverty alleviation, such as the Millennium Development Goals. At the same time, simply increasing public spending - without seeking improvements in the efficiency of that spending - is unlikely to reap substantial benefits. The productivity of public spending varies enormously across countries. Ethiopia and Malawi spend roughly the same amount per person on primary education - with very different outcomes. Peru and Thailand spend vastly different amounts - with similar outcomes.

The Report concludes that no one size fits all. The type of service delivery mechanism needs to be tailored to characteristics of the service and circumstances of the country. For instance, if the service is easy to monitor, such as immunization, and it is in a country where the politics are pro-poor, such as Norway, then it can be delivered by the central government directly, or contracted out. But if the politics of the country are such that these resources are likely to be diverted to the well-off by way of patronage, and the service is difficult to monitor, such as student learning, then arrangements that strengthen the client’s power as much as possible are necessary. Means-tested voucher schemes, as in Colombia or Bangladesh, community-managed schools as in El Salvador, or transparent, rule-based programs, such as Mexico’s ‘Progresa", are more likely to work for poor people.

Taking good examples nationwide

Innovating with service delivery arrangements will not be enough, according to the report. What is needed are ways of widening the reach of these innovations or ‘scaling up’ so the entire country can benefit. To achieve this, the report emphasizes the role of information - as a stimulant for public action, as a catalyst for change, as an input to making other reforms work. In Uganda, publishing in the newspaper the fact that only 13 percent of the money due to primary schools was actually reaching the schools, galvanized the populace. The share now is 80 percent and the entire budget of the school is posted on the schoolroom door.

Systematic evaluations of these innovations, with a control group assessed alongside the "treatment group," gives policymakers confidence that what they are seeing is real. Such an evaluation of Mexico’s Progresa led to the program being scaled up to cover 20 percent of the Mexican population.

The authors of the report warn that achieving these reforms will be difficult. "There is no silver bullet," says Devarajan, "just the hard slog of reforming institutions and power relations. But the needs of the world’s poor people are urgent. And services have too often failed them. We must act now."

The report and related materials are available at

Rate this content
Average of 136 ratings 
Rating 2.49 / 4 MoyenMoyenMoyenMoyen
Same author:
 flecheThe 2017 Atlas of Sustainable Development Goals: a new visual guide to data and development
 flecheImproved water source (% of population with access)
 flecheDigital Dividends
 flecheIndigenous Latin America in the twenty-first century : the first decade
 flecheClimate-Driven Water Scarcity Could Hit Economic Growth by Up to 6 Percent in Some Regions, Says World Bank
 flechePrimary completion rate, both sexes (%)
 flecheWhere Are Forests Being Lost and Gained?
 flecheWaste Not, Want Not – Solid Waste at the Heart of Sustainable Development
 flecheImproving Food Security and Agricultural Productivity: A Priority for Burkina Faso
 flecheBreaking the Gender Earnings Gap
 flecheIndigenous Latin America in the twenty-first century
 flecheWhat challenges will Latin America face in 2016?
 flecheYear in Review: 2015 in 12 charts
 flecheNew $500 million initiative to boost large scale climate action in developing countries
 flecheHeads of State and CEOs Declare Support for Carbon Pricing to Transform Global Economy
 flecheImmediate Push on Climate-Smart Development Can Keep More than 100 Million People Out of Poverty
 flecheA New Approach to Cities: Everyone Counts
 flecheLeaders Unite in Calling for a Price on Carbon Ahead of Paris Climate Talks
 flecheWorld Bank Forecasts Global Poverty to Fall Below 10% for First Time; Major Hurdles Remain in Goal to End Poverty by 2030
 flecheSouth Asia Not Taking Full Economic Advantage of Urbanization
 flecheJobs Without Borders
 flecheAide à l’éducation : le Groupe de la Banque mondiale va doubler les financements axés sur des résultats pour les porter à 5 milliards de dollars au cours des cinq prochaines années
 flecheRemittances growth to slow sharply in 2015, as Europe and Russia stay weak; pick up expected next year
 flecheWorld Bank President Outlines Strategy to End Poverty, Welcomes New Development Partners
 flecheBrazil, Colombia and Peru are among the countries of the world with the most water
 flecheBreaking the Cycle of Chronic Poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean
 flecheClean Air and Healthy Lungs: How to Better Tackle Air Pollution
 flecheWho Gains and Who Loses from Plunging Oil Prices in the Middle East and North Africa Region?
 flecheGlobal Economic Prospects to Improve in 2015, But Divergent Trends Pose Downside Risks
 flecheFighting Climate Change & Poverty at the Same Time
 flecheWorld Is Locked into ~1.5°C Warming & Risks Are Rising, New Climate Report Finds
 flecheNew Evidence Highlights What Works to Empower Girls and Young Women
 flecheWomen Empowered by Solar Energy in Bangladesh
 flecheHappy Cows Help Save the Planet: Climate Smart Agriculture in Costa Rica
 flecheFood Price Watch, May 2014: First Quarterly Increase Since August 2012; The Role of Food Prices in Food Riots
 flechePoor Quality Education Holding Back South Asia, World Bank says
 flecheNew Study Adds Up the Benefits of Climate-Smart Development in Lives, Jobs, and GDP
 flecheHillary Clinton and Jim Yong Kim: Empowering Women & Girls Improves the World
 flecheWarmer World Will Keep Millions of People Trapped in Poverty, Says New Report
 flecheWhat Will It Take to Achieve Learning For All?
 flecheWorld Bank Urges Governments to Think Green for Inclusive Growth
 flecheDeveloping World Lags on Global Targets Related to Food and Nutrition, Says IMF-World Bank Report
 flecheWorld Development Report: Gender Equality and Development
 flecheDisclosure of Assets and Income by Public Officials Is Crucial to Curbing Corruption, Finds New StAR Study
 flecheGender Equality: the Right and Smart Thing to Do – World Bank Report
 flecheCitizen security, justice and jobs key to breaking cycles of political and criminal violence: World Bank report
 flechee-Atlas of global development launched by World Bank easy mapping with new data visualization tool
 flecheAdvancing food security in a changing climate
 flecheWorld Bank’s fund for the poorest receives qlmost $50 billion in record funding
 flecheNew report sees cities as central to climate action
 flecheWorld Bank-UN report charts path to prevent death and destruction from natural hazards
 flecheWorld Bank launches new tools to empower innovative solutions to development challenges
 flecheDeveloping countries come to the global economy’s rescue
 flecheProtecting land rights is key to successful large-scale land acquisitions
 flecheIntegrate water management, help countries on hydropower, says review of World Bank Group water strategy
 flecheCountries have opportunities to boost global investment competitiveness, finds World Bank Group
 flecheExperts: opening data will drive global knowledge
 flecheWorld Bank frees up development data
 flecheWorld Bank reforms voting power, gets $86 billion boost
 flecheGlobal trade logistics improving, but more needed to boost recovery
 flecheWorld Bank data now in Google search results
 flecheAdapting to climate change to cost US$75-100 Billion a year
 flecheDoing Business 2010: Governments set new record in business regulation reform
 flecheBangladesh: Who migrates overseas and is it worth their while?
 flecheHigh speed internet is key to economic growth and job creation in developing countries, says new World Bank Group report
 flecheCrisis reveals growing finance gaps for developing countries
 flecheRecovery rides on the 'G-2'
 flecheWorld Bank maps local and global economic geography, calls for greater integration
 flecheNew data show 1.4 billion live on less than us$1.25 a day, but progress against poverty remains strong
 flecheWater and Climate Change
 flecheBusiness Push Benefits Poor
 flecheDeveloping countries growth resilient in the face of financial turmoil and soaring food and energy prices
 flecheNew report sheds light on success strategies of fast-growing countries
 flecheGlobal monitoring report warns on MDG goals
 flecheDeveloping World greenhouse gas projects face carbon market bottlenecks
 flecheState and Trends of the Carbon Market 2008
 flecheIndia top receiver of migrant remittances in 2007, followed by China and Mexico
 flecheGlobalization requires education reforms in Middle East and North Africa, report says
 flecheReport "The road not traveled: Education reform in the Middle East and North Africa"
 flecheDeveloping countries to cushion rich-country slowdown in 2008
 flecheAfrica high on Japan’s agenda in 2008
 flecheIn search of clean energy to meet China’s needs
 flecheAfrica Development Indicators (ADI) 2007
 flecheSpreading and sustaining growth in Africa
 flecheThe human factor in re-engineering government
 fleche“Catalyzing the future: an inclusive & sustainable globalization” - Remarks of Robert B. Zoellick
 flecheWorld Bank Group Pledges $3.5 Billion for Poorest Countries
 flecheWorld Bank and UNODC to Pursue Stolen Asset Recovery
 flecheGlobal Monitoring Report 2007: Confronting the Challenges of Gender Equality and Fragile States
 flecheGreater Attention Needed to Gender Equality and Fragile States to Reach Global Targets by 2015, Says World Bank-IMF Report
 flecheGlobal Economic Prospects 2007: Managing the Next Wave of Globalization
 flecheGlobal Economic Prospects 2007: Managing the Next Wave of Globalization
 flecheWorld Bank Allocates Record Amount of Income For Poorest Countries

 flecheA Funding Call for Nutrition
 flecheSending The Money Home
 flecheInformation and Communications for Development 2006: Global Trends and Policies / World Bank
 flechePoverty reduction and growth : virtuous and vicious circles
 flecheLatin America Needs To Cut Poverty To Boost Growth
 flecheLe moment d'agir est venu
 flecheLatin America: A Need to Boost Spending on Infrastructure
 flecheA New Spark in Romania's Village Schools
 flecheThirty Years of Life in a Favela
 flecheNiger Receives Emergency Aid
 flecheWorking Together to Beat the Heat
 flecheLending Rises, Quality Remains High - World Bank Releases Results for FY 05
 flecheStatement By Paul Wolfowitz, President Of The World Bank, At Conclusion Of G8 Summit
 flecheG-8 Gleneagles Summit and Development
 flecheAid Flows, Debt Relief, And Economic Growth On The Rise In Africa, But Threats To Poverty Alleviation Remain: World Bank Report
 flecheGrowing on the Ashes of Conflict
 flecheDebt Relief
 flecheNew World Bank President Paul Wolfowitz Takes Office
 flechePrêmio Banco Mundial de Cidadania 2005 - Voz Mulher
 flecheNovo Relatorio Aponta Crise Mundial de Aposentadorias
 flecheDeveloping Countries At Odds Over Preferences In Farm Trade Talks
 flecheDevelopment in an Insecure World
 flecheProtect & Promote Poor People’s Knowledge To Raise Their Incomes
 flecheWolfensohn, James D.
 flecheWorld Bank Commits $250 Million for Tsunami-Affected Countries
 flecheEnvironmental Degradation And Climate Change Threaten Development Prospects
 flecheUnited Nations Report Offers New Vision Of Collective Security
 flecheGlobal Economic Prospects 2005: Trade, Regionalism and Development
 flecheRegional Trade Pacts Must Create – Not Divert – Trade to Reduce Poverty: World Bank Report
 flecheMillennium Development Goals : Countdown to 2015 - Gender Equity
 flecheEast Asia: Global Uncertainties Threaten to Mar 2005
 flecheChina Gives Bank Poverty Award
 flecheThe World Bank Leading The Way In Biodiversity
 flecheDebt relief plan eludes IMF Group; Issue likely to be resolved next year
 flecheEradicating Poverty For Stability And Peace
 flecheEasing Policy Risks, Costs And Barriers To Competition Keys To Faster Growth, Less Poverty: World Development Report 2005
 flecheIndigenous Culture Fundamental To Global Development
 flecheWorld Bank
 flecheDevelopment Education Program
 flecheMillenium Development Goals related regional charts
 flecheUniversal primary education
 flecheGlobal poverty evolution (1981-2001)
 flecheWhy Development Policy Lending's Time Has Come
 flecheWorld Bank Paper Urges Major Easing Of Israeli Closure Measures And Stepped-Up Palestinian Reform Efforts
 flecheUnhealthy Environment, Unhealthy People
 flechePoor Nations Agree On Flexible Approach To Kickstart Global Trade Talks
 flecheCities Put New Face on Poverty
 flecheNew AIDS Report Says Latin America Needs Broader Civil Society Participation To Battle Epidemic
 flecheIFC Invests in Caspian Oil and Pipeline Projects
 flecheWorld Bank's Wolfensohn: Poverty Fueling Global Unrest
 flecheWorld Bank-IMF Annual Meetings Open in Dubai
 flecheWorld Bank Grant Launches Bank-WTO Assistance on Standards
 flecheStatement by Horst Köhler, Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund, on the Work Program of the Executive Board, October 30,2002
 flecheRich Countries Should Show the Way on Trade
 flecheInvesting in Better Globalization sous-titre : Remarks by Horst Köhler Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund at the Council on Foreign Relations Washington, D.C.
 flecheSustaining Development; Our Opportunity in Johannesburg
 flecheWorld Bank Urges More Balanced Global Approach To Development
 flecheAgreement Reached on Increased Funding For Poorest Countries
 flecheWorld Bank President Outlines Post-Monterrey Action Plan to Development Committee
 flecheWorld Bank Anticipates Global Upturn, Urges Increased Help to Poor Countries
 flecheA Partnership for Development and Peace
 flecheWorld Bank estimates cost of reaching the millennium development goals at $40-60 billion annually in additional aid
 flecheGlobalization, Growth and Poverty: Building an Inclusive World Economy
 flechePoverty To Rise in Wake Of Terrorist Attacks in US
 flecheZoellick, Lamy, Wolfensohn Discuss Growth and Development World Bank Calls for 'Development Round' at Qatar
 flecheWorld Bank Reviews Strategy, Launches Projects To Expand Health Coverage, Restructure Banks
 flechePutting Social and 'Green' Responsibility on the Corporate Agenda
 flecheWorld Bank Development Economics Conference Goes Online
 flecheWorld Bank Cancels Academic Meeting in Spain
 flecheWorld Bank Calls For New Compact To Fight Global Poverty
Keywords   go