Ref. :  000036599
Date :  2014-03-05
Language :  English
Home Page / The whole website
fr / es / de / po / en

The Trillion Dollar Question: Who Owns Emerging Market Government Debt

Author :  FMI / IMF


There are a trillion reasons to care about who owns emerging market debt. That’s how much money global investors have poured into in these government bonds in recent years —$1 trillion. Who owns it, for how long and why it changes over time can shed light on the risks; a sudden reversal of money flowing out of a country can hurt. Shifts in the investor base also can have implications for a government’s borrowing costs.

What investors do next is a big question for emerging markets, and our new analysis takes some of the guesswork out of who owns your debt. The more you know your investors, the better you understand the potential risks and how to deal with them.

Some of the facts

We compiled comparable and standardized estimates of the investor base of emerging markets’ government debt using the same approach we designed last year to track who owns advanced economy government debt.

We use data from 24 emerging market countries and we’ve made it available for anyone interested in further research (Figure 1). The data covers the period from 2004 through June 2013.

image

By our estimates, half a trillion dollars in foreign investment poured into emerging market government bonds from 2010 until 2012 alone, most of it from foreign financial institutions that aren’t banks (large institutional investors, hedge funds, sovereign wealth funds). These investors held about $800 billion of the debt—80 percent of the total—at end-2012.

We also calculate that foreign central banks held about $40 to $80 billion of the debt, and their holdings appear to be concentrated in seven countries: Brazil, China, Indonesia, Poland, Malaysia, Mexico and South Africa.

Why this money poured in to emerging market economies over the last decade is partly related to improvements in public debt management. In particular, emerging markets have extended the maturity of their debt profile, cut down issuance of floating rate debt, and reduced foreign currency debt. This made their public balance sheet more resilient to exchange rate and interest rate shocks, and reduced risks on the supply-side of government debt. Partly as a result, foreign interest in emerging market government debt rose sharply in recent years.

Rising foreign participation in emerging market government debt markets creates opportunities and new risks, notably on the demand side. Rising foreign participation in government debt markets can help reduce borrowing costs and spread risks more broadly among investors, but it can also raise external funding risks for countries. Moreover, having a view of investors across countries is essential for understanding the dynamics of global demand for government debt. Changes in global investor’s allocations among countries are important because they can affect many countries all at once.

Before, during and after the global financial crisis

We found that foreign investors distinguished among emerging market economies in three distinct periods—before, during and after the global financial crisis. Before the crisis, they showed moderate differentiation among countries: some received inflows while others faced outflows. As it usually happens, this differentiation became much sharper during the crisis. However, during the third period (2010–12), we found that foreign flows became almost always positive and much less differentiated (Figure 2).

image

Part of these inflows can be explained by improving economic fundamentals in a number of emerging markets in this period. Five emerging markets reached or regained investment grade status during 2010–12: Colombia, Indonesia, Latvia, Romania, and Uruguay. Most emerging markets weathered the crisis well, with a relatively quick return to high growth. This may have raised expectations of currency appreciation in emerging markets, attracting further demand from foreign investors. At the same time, even countries whose credit ratings deteriorated or did not improve during this period continued to receive inflows against the background of near-zero interest rates in advanced economies.

Emerging markets can prepare

Last year we developed a framework to examine how potential sudden stops in foreign money may impact government debt markets. In our new analysis, we’ve run illustrative scenarios to see what might happen under different circumstances. We designed these to assess the impact of a shock, not to predict the likelihood of one.

The scenarios show that, for a given level of foreign participation in government bond markets, countries with the following characteristics would be less sensitive to external funding risks:

- lower debt-to-GDP ratio

- lower gross financing needs

- more developed domestic financial systems

- larger liquidity buffers to protect against external shocks.


So the scenarios illustrate the importance of extending the maturity of government debt, developing a local investor base, and maintaining liquidity buffers to mitigate the potential harm from a sudden outflow of foreign funding. Countries that had these mitigating measures, such as Mexico and Poland, faced less pressure on bonds yields during the summer of 2013, despite having higher foreign ownership of government debt.

For all these reasons, emerging markets need to carefully track who owns their debt and for how long. They need to beef up their communications with their investor base to understand their needs.

Understanding the benefits and risks of foreign ownership in emerging market debt is key. Is there some perfect mix of domestic and foreign investors? Stay tuned for the upcoming analysis in the next issue of the Global Financial Stability Report for more on that.


Rate this content
 
 
 
Average of 185 ratings 
Rating 2.41 / 4 MoyenMoyenMoyenMoyen
Same author:
 flecheIMF Sees Subdued Global Growth, Warns Economic Stagnation Could Fuel Protectionist Calls
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook October 2016
 flecheGlobal Financial Stability: Vulnerabilities, Legacies, and Policy Challenges
 flecheMiddle East Outlook Sees Modest Improvement, But Risks Remain
 flecheLower Potential Growth: A New Reality
 flecheFinancial Services Access Vital to Central Africa Growth
 flecheIMF Agenda Focuses on Achieving More Dynamic, Job-Rich Global Economy
 flecheJobs, Growth, Fairness Top List of Priorities for Arab Countries
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook Reports
 flecheGlobal Economy Turning Corner of Great Recession, But Obstacles Ahead
 flecheDespite new risks, global recovery seen gaining strength
 flecheG-20 ministers agree ‘historic’ reforms in IMF governance
 flecheIMF enhances crisis prevention toolkit
 flecheAfrica’s economic transformation—the road ahead
 flecheLe secteur privé gagne du terrain en Afrique
 flecheThe IMF response to the global crisis: meeting the needs of low-income countries
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook (April 2009) - press point for chapter 3 "From recession to recovery: how soon and how strong?"
 flecheIMF calls for urgent action as third wave of global crisis hits poorest countries
 flecheGlobal Financial Stability - Report Market Update
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook - October 2008 (Full report)
 flecheThe Rise of Africa's "Frontier" Markets
 flecheLe FMI précise comment il surveillera les politiques économiques
 flecheGlobal financial stability report
 flecheIMF Shifts Focus to Key Global Economic and Financial Concerns
 flecheIMF Board of Governors adopts Quota and Voice reforms by large margin
 flecheInternational Working Group of Sovereign Wealth Funds is established to facilitate work on voluntary principles
 flecheGlobal Financial Stability Report (Executive summary)
 flecheGlobal governance: new players, new rules
 flecheIMF Managing Director highlights progress on IMF reform agenda and warns IMF Board of Governors of slower global growth
 flecheStrauss-Kahn to press ahead on IMF reform
 flecheThe rise of sovereign wealth funds
 flecheUrban poverty
 flecheThe urban revolution
 flecheGlobal Growth Seen at 5.2 pct in 2007
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook - 2007
 flecheRenewing the IMF's Commitment to Low-Income Countries
 flecheGlobalization and Inflation - World Economic Outlook
 flecheIMF to Extend 100 Percent Debt Relief for 19 Countries Under the Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative
 flecheNew Report Calls For Urgent Action To Cut Global Poverty and Win Better Development Results For Poor Countries
 flecheRato y Figaredo, Rodrigo de
 flecheExpanding trade and unleashing growth: The prospects for lasting poverty reduction
 flecheCan the East Asian Miracle Persist?
 flecheEmerging Asia: Outlook, Challenges, and India's Growing Role
 flecheWorld Economic Outlook
 flecheCommuniqué of the Ministers and Governors of the Group of Ten
 fleche"Why Globalization Works" Economic forums and international seminars
 flecheWorking paper : External Debt Sustainability in HIPC Completion Point Countries
 flecheChina's rapid economic growth and integration into the global economy
 flecheInternational Monetary Fund
 flecheIMF Members' Quotas and Voting Power, and IMF Board of Governors
 flecheIMF Executive Board Discusses Euro Area Policies
 flecheToward a Stronger Europe in the Global Economy
 flecheThe IMF Stands Ready to Help Iraq
13
SEARCH
Keywords   go
in