Ref. :  000029482
Date :  2008-05-15
Language :  English
Home Page / The whole website
fr / es / de / po / en

FAO Director-General responds to criticism by Senegalese President


In a 10-point press statement, FAO Director-General Jacques Diouf responds to recent criticisms of the Organization by the President of Senegal.

The FAO Director-General is currently working on all continents to deal with the global food crisis, together with Member States, development partners and other UN agencies. While duty-bound to defend an organization of 191 member countries that he was re-elected, unopposed, to lead in 2005, he has no intention of being distracted by a controversy motivated by Senegalese domestic politics with the Head of State to whom he owes respect and esteem.

However the issues raised need objective answers:

1. Regarding the “institutions which, in Niger, said there was a famine”. Which are those institutions? Is FAO one of them? In an article in “Le Quotidien” on 27/11/2007 the journalist Paul Diene Faye wrote, not without humour: “Senegal may not yet have a famine, or at least the Director-General of FAO, the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization, doesn’t want to say so. The reason, explains Mr Jacques Diouf, is that it is not FAO’s role to say which parts of the world are affected by famine. Its mandate, he explains, is to publish a document entitled “The State of Food Insecurity in the World”. FAO’s Director-General stresses that this is not an “instant” document; it is prepared over a long period of time, and with all due precaution.”

2. As to the statement that, “Feeding the poor is charity”: Does FAO distribute food? What bilateral, regional and multilateral institutions do that job?

3. “Technical assistance to agriculture is assistance to men and women standing on their own two feet”. Technical assistance is precisely what FAO does:

* with field training activities, including the Technical Cooperation Programme (TCP) and South-South cooperation (1,473 experts made available to developing countries);

* by strengthening veterinary services (against Foot and Mouth Disease, Rift Valley Fever, African Swine Fever, Contagious Bovine Pleuropneumonia, Avian Influenza, Newcastle disease, Peste des Petits Ruminants, Bluetongue disease, and plant health services (strengthening early-warning and response capacities against desert locusts and wheat stem rust);

* by using integrated biological control, halving pesticide quantities by 50 percent and obtaining a 15 percent increase in rice production;

* by disseminating hand and foot pumps, irrigation channels, small dams, metal storage silos;

* through projects aimed at increased production of rice, corn, cassava, vegetables, micro-gardens, poultry farming, small ruminants and the introduction and development of aquaculture;

* by re-establishing the productive potential of farmers, herders and fishers following natural disasters such as floods, droughts, tsunamis, earthquakes, hurricanes, cyclones;

* by providing specialists, farmers, researchers, teachers and students with WAICENT, an Internet site that which receives four million visits a month for information and statistics on agricultural production, trade, water, soil and farm inputs;

* through the establishment with WHO of 200 Codex Alimentarius norms to protect consumers and serve as benchmarks for resolving disputes over WTO sanitary and phytosanitary regulations.

4. “The winter planting season, starting end May, early June, will soon be upon us in the Sahel. It lasts three months on average. Let us seize this opportunity because it won’t come again for another year.”. Almost five months ago, on 17 December 2007, FAO drew international attention to the importance of the 2008 harvest, and launched an "Initiative on Soaring Food Prices”. It was vital for developing country farmers to have access to the seeds, fertilizer and feed they needed but whose price had increased. The Director-General announced that FAO, despite not being a financing institution, was contributing US$17 million to the initiative to increase agricultural productivity and appealed for the mobilization of US$1.7 billion. Such resources, in cash or kind, go through bilateral or multilateral channels under specific agreements with governments. It is therefore not correct to say that, “FAO in turn announced that it needed US$1.7 billion”. FAO’s appeal was approved by UN and the Bretton Woods Institutions at a meeting in Berne, Switzerland, from 28 to 29. It is mentioned in press communiqué of 29 April by the UN Secretary-General.

In December 2007 in Senegal, together with development partners and the Ministers for Agriculture, Water management and others, on 22 December 2007 with the media, and then again on 17 March 2008 with the technical and economic ministries, the FAO Director-General held a series of meetings to alert national authorities and public opinion to the risks of a food crisis and to discuss measures needed to present the programme. The meetings were widely covered by the national press. Why were appropriate actions not implemented then?

5. “The way ahead is clear to that part of the international community which really wants to help – innovative investment agriculture in Africa.”. In the first year of his mandate in June 1994, the FAO Director-General launched the Special Programme for Food Security now operational in 100 countries. Priority is given to small-scale water harvesting and irrigation works by rural communities. National programmes featuring agricultural policy measures, institutional capacity-building and investment programmes (using a village-by-village approach) were initiated in 15 countries and are under formulation in 36 more. For 14 years the Director-General of FAO has been saying that Africa’s “agricultural lottery” has to cease (96 percent of farmland is rainfed while the continent only uses 4 percent of its renewable water resources). He has reiterated time and again that investments should focus on irrigation works, storage and packaging (post-harvest losses range from 40 to 60 percent), rural roads, slaughterhouses, fishing harbours, cold supply chains. All these points are contained in the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP) prepared with FAO and adopted by the African Union Summit of July 2003. The costs were evaluated to facilitate the financing. At the request of African leaders, FAO also helped translate the CAADP into national programmes in 51 countries.

Since 2001, FAO has helped many regional economic organizations elaborate regional food security programmes (RFSP): In Africa the regional food security programme of UEMOA (2002), CEDEAO (2002), SADC (2002, still to be approved), COMESA (2002), UMA (2001), IGAD (2002), CEEAC (prepared in 2003 and adopted in 2004), CEMAC (2003) and CEN SAD (under formulation). Similar programmes were prepared in other world regions, i.e. the Caribbean (CARICOM, 2002) the Pacific countries (PIF, 2002), South Asia, SAARC, under formulation), Central Asia (ECO, under formulation) and South America (MERCOSUR, draft prepared in 2005).

If, as is clear from the facts, the required investments were never made, does that make FAO responsible? Which bilateral, regional and international organizations have reduced their support to agriculture to dangerous levels? Does FAO’s mandate include financing and investing in agriculture? Who took the decision that cut agriculture’s share of development aid from 17 percent at the beginning of the eighties to 3 percent in 2005? Didn’t FAO organize a World Food Summit back in 2002 to draw the international community’s attention to the situation and underline the absence of political will and resources to fight food insecurity? At the 2001 G8 Summit, in which the Director-General took part, in the United Nations General Assembly, in ECOSOC, and at the 2004 Extraordinary Summit of the African Union on Agriculture and Water in Syrte, didn’t FAO draw the attention of the world’s leaders to the situation and suggest solutions?

6. “FAO as an institution should be held responsible. The present situation largely stems from its failure”. Agricultural specialists, economists and journalists have all analyzed the causes of the food crisis and pinpointed the following factors:

- as concerns supply: agricultural production has been affected by climate change (floods, droughts, harsher winters, cyclones, hurricanes, earthquakes). Cereals stocks stand at their lowest level since 1980. Does FAO have a national territory with farmland and citizens, including farmers who produce food? Does it hold food stocks?

- as concerns demand: the world’s population is set to increase from six to nine billion in 2050. Does FAO bring 78.5 million babies into the world every year? Again, demand in emerging nations is growing very rapidly, especially in China and India. With their GDP growth of 8 to 12 percent as a result of national policies and the hard work of their peoples, they have been able to generate the income they need to improve their populations’ diets. FAO does not regret its excellent cooperation with those countries. Lastly, new demand for biofuels has diverted crops from food to energy. Is FAO responsible for the national incentives, the subsidies and the tariff protection, used to develop the sector?

- at international market level: support from OECD countries to their farmers in terms of Total Support Estimate (TSE) was US$372 billion in 2006, while duties, tariffs and technical trade barriers have also discriminated against agriculture in developing countries. Tough negotiations are taking place on these issues in the Doha Round. Does FAO determine and apply decisions taken in international trade relations? Again, the agricultural policies of developing countries have been liberalized and farmer support structures (extension, inputs, storage, marketing, price stabilization) have been gradually eliminated (better management of those structures would have protected their smallholders from the forces of an unequal international market). Was it FAO that pressured developing countries to adopt those policies? We also have the problem of financial speculation. Investment funds speculate on futures markets and help push up the price of commodities, including food commodities. Does FAO control those funds?

7. “Financially speaking, FAO is a bottomless pit”. FAO’s biennial budget is voted by the Conference of all its Member Nations. It amounts to the budget of the Ministry of Agriculture of South Africa. Various countries contribute according to a United Nations scale (Senegal’s share is 0.004 percent of the total). It is used to implement a programme of work and budget examined and approved by the Finance and Programme Committees. It contains a detailed list of all budget headings for personnel, equipment and running expenses. FAO’s accounts are regularly audited. They have always been approved for every biennium. Between 1994/95 and 2006/07, the budget shrank 22% in real terms, staffing was cut by 24.6%, while the number of Member Nations rose from 169 to 191.

8. “I told them (FAO’s top management) that if you continue ... I’ll have you brought to justice, you have to reimburse the 20 percent of the money collected on our behalf”. It is superfluous to comment on such charges. FAO is a United Nations organization whose collective, intergovernmental management system is determined and protected by international treaties guaranteeing its independence and immunity to unilateral interference by individual countries. Senegal has ratified these treaties and has undertaken to respect the Organization’s statute.

9. Lastly, under the United Nations system, agencies, funds and programmes are complementary and the Secretary-General is responsible for coordinating them. In 2005 and 2006 a High-Level Panel on United Nations System-wide Coherence chaired by the Prime Ministers of Norway, Pakistan and Mozambique undertook an in-depth study of how the United Nations worked and published a report on how the system could operate more efficiently and effectively in the field. The Ambassadors and Permanent Representatives of the 192 UN Member Countries regularly discuss the measures proposed at global and national level. FAO was naturally associated with the exercise and is participating actively, not least through eight ongoing pilot field projects.

10. Senegal has thinkers and intellectuals of international standing; some have left the country and are teaching in some of the top universities in the West. FAO is prepared, if the Government so wishes, to work with experts at the technical and economic ministries, at the Senegalese Agricultural Research Institute, at the Universities of Dakar and Saint-Louis as well as at the Senegalese Academy of Sciences, among other institutions, in order to examine the causes of the world food crisis and to consider possible short-, medium- and long-term solutions, the risks and opportunities for Senegal. The Government could thus benefit from the in-depth studies of competent people and obtain pertinent conclusions and analyses that could serve as a solid basis for concerted action aimed at ensuring Senegal’s agricultural development and food security.


Contact:
Christopher Matthews, Media Relations, FAO, christopher.matthews@fao.org, (+39) 06 570 53762


Countries : 

Rate this content
 
 
 
Average of 119 ratings 
Rating 2.50 / 4 MoyenMoyenMoyenMoyen
Same author:
 flecheIs the planet approaching "peak fish"? Not so fast, study says
 flecheForests and trees are key for a sustainable future
 flecheProtecting the right to a childhood
 flecheDealing with drought
 flecheMexico’s Guatemalan refugees: where are they now?
 flecheSouth Sudan famine ebbs, but situation still desperate as hunger spreads
 flecheUsing real-time satellite data to track water productivity in agriculture
 fleche108 million people in food crisis countries face severe acute food insecurity – situation worsening
 fleche10 questions – How much do you know about forests and energy?
 flecheBuilding greener cities: nine benefits of urban trees
 fleche10 million hectares a year in need of restoration along the Great Green Wall
 flecheThe state of food and agriculture 2016
 flecheThe State of the World’s Forests 2016
 flecheNutrition and Food Systems
 flecheThe People’s Manual on the Guidelines on Governance of Land, Fisheries and Forests
 flecheThe role of pulses in nutrition-sensitive agriculture
 fleche2015–2016 El Niño - Early action and response for agriculture, food security and nutrition
 flecheCommunity-based forestry can be a driving force in boosting sustainability and people’s livelihoods
 flecheFreebee: How bees can help raise food security of 2 billion smallholders at no cost
 flechePETROCARIBE: 10 years of struggle against hunger and poverty
 flecheSoils are endangered, but the degradation can be rolled back
 flecheSyria: Better rains improve wheat production, but food security situation remains bleak
 flecheA body of evidence: What climate change implies for global food security and trade
 flecheFAO hails G20 focus on building sustainable food systems and reducing food loss and waste
 flecheAgriculture bears major brunt of disaster impacts, new report says
 flecheAgriculture key to Caribbean food security and coping with climate change
 flecheLakes and rivers key to livelihoods of millions
 flecheGenetic diversity a hidden tool in coping with climate change
 flecheEbola leaves hundreds of thousands facing hunger in three worst-hit countries
 flecheThe State of Food Insecurity in the World 2014
 flecheNew roadmap for boosting small-scale and family forest producers
 fleche“Top Ten” list of food-borne parasites released
 flecheFAO Food Price Index dips for third consecutive month
 flecheCountries recognize vital role of small-scale fishers
 flecheFAO and National Geographic announce collaboration exploring future of food
 flecheGlobal Oceans Action Summit for Food Security and Blue Growth opens in The Hague:
High-level gathering focuses on identifying solutions for healthy oceans

 flecheAngola, Brazil and FAO sign South-South Cooperation agreement
 flecheFAO calls for increased vigilance and preparedness in neighboring countries
 flecheWorld food prices stay high, but steady
 flecheWorld Food Situation
 flecheThe multiple dimensions of food security
 flecheBiofuel development should not compromise food security, says CFS
 flecheSustainable Food Systems for Food Security and Nutrition
 flecheFood waste harms climate, water, land and biodiversity – new FAO report
 flecheGlobal food prices continue to drop
 flecheFAO highlights the potential of South-South cooperation
 flecheQuinoa, an Andean crop that can play a significant role in eradicating hunger
 flecheFood systems for better nutrition
 flecheWorld cereal production set to reach historic high in 2013
 flecheLinking farmers to moving markets
 flecheForest products critical to fight hunger - including insects
 flecheNo green economy without blue economy, says FAO
 flecheInternational Day of Forests 2013
 flecheFood waste is a growing concern next to food losses
 flecheThe State of Food Insecurity in the World 2012
 flecheGlobally almost 870 million chronically undernourished - new hunger report
 flecheUN launches new programme to empower rural women and girls
 flecheRecurring droughts highlight need to better manage water resources, safeguard food security
 flecheImpacts of Bioenergy on Food Security
 flecheFAO Food Price Index up 6 percent
 flecheRural Women and the Millennium Development Goals
 flecheMatch Day Against Hunger (31st March -- 2nd April 2012)
 flecheConsensus reached on guidelines for land tenure and access to fisheries and forests
 flecheProfessional Football against Hunger 2012 campaign kicks off
 flecheWorld Water Day 2012
 flecheFAO-EC project to promote climate-smart farming
 flecheCorruption undermining land access, development
 flecheTen proposals to safeguard the ocean
 flecheWorld hunger report 2011: High, volatile prices set to continue
 flecheWomen – key to food security
FAO at work 2010-2011

 flecheRome emergency meeting rallies to aid Horn of Africa
 flecheAnnan warns hunger could become permanent disaster
 flecheClimate change: major impacts on water for farming
 flecheGood forest governance key for climate change schemes
 flecheNew humanitarian food security platform launched
 flecheForests and climate change in the Mediterranean
 flechePotentially catastrophic climate impacts on food production over the long-term
 flecheReducing poverty by growing fuel and food
 flecheFish consumption reaches all-time high
 flechePolicy guide for countries hit hard by high food prices
 flecheFAO backs indigenous people
 flecheMore countries taking action to safeguard animal genetic diversity
 flecheOne trillion food import bill as prices rise
 flecheAfrica crop tool launched: Interactive 43-nation guide on what to plant, when and where
 flecheCrop biodiversity: use it or lose it - FAO launches 2nd State of the World’s Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture report
 flecheForest biodiversity at risk
 fleche22 countries in protracted crisis
 flecheFirst global guidelines for aquaculture certification finalized
 flecheGrowing food in greener cities
 flecheFood price volatility a major threat to food security, but no indication of a global food crisis
 fleche925 million in chronic hunger worldwide
 flecheThe safe use of wastewater in agriculture offers multiple benefits
 flecheFAO launches NASA-developed fire monitoring system
 flecheFAO provides free access to statistics treasure trove
 flecheSome regulation of food futures markets desirable
 flecheNew market access rules, economic crisis affecting seafood industry
 flecheFact sheet: The international fish trade and world fisheries
 flecheNew FAO report assesses dairy greenhouse gas emissions
 flecheWorld deforestation decreases, but remains alarming in many countries
 flecheAfrica organic export drive
 flecheTowards a more sustainable livestock sector - FAO report analyzes the rapidly changing global livestock production
 flecheHigh tea prices - Better weather conditions mean prices should stabilise in 2010
 flecheGroundbreaking treaty on illegal fishing approved
 flecheFAO calls for world hunger strike against hunger
 flecheWorld Summit on Food Security (November 16-18 2009 - Rome, Italy)
 flechePromoting climate-smart agriculture - Report explores mutual benefits, trade-offs in tackling hunger and climate change
 flecheEconomic crisis is devastating for the world's hungry : 1.02 billion hungry people in 2009
 fleche2050: A third more mouths to feed
 flecheFAO initiates debate on declaration for World Summit on Food Security - Calls for eradication of hunger by 2025 and for more investment in agriculture
 flecheOne sixth of humanity undernourished - more than ever before
 flecheAgriculture more resilient to global crisis than other sectors
 flecheAgriculture is essential for facing climate change
 flecheLand acquisitions in Africa pose risks for poor
 flecheFood prices remain high in developing countries
 flecheStudy shows bioenergy benefits for rural poor
 flecheChina and FAO sign historic $30 million deal
 flecheNew FAO food price database launched
 flecheState of the World’s Forests 2009
 flecheVirtual Water: How much water does it take to produce...?
 flecheForests and the global economy: 10 million new jobs
 flecheFAO's Kevern discusses the implications of climate change for fisheries and aquaculture (State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture" report)
 flecheWorld fisheries must prepare for climate change
 flecheDespite bumper 2008 harvests, high prices persist in many poor countries
 flecheFarming must change to feed the world : FAO expert urges more sustainable approach
 flecheVers un plan d’action mondial pour l’eau - Réunion internationale à Rome pour préparer le Forum mondial de l’eau
 fleche"Food should be a national security issue" - Interview with M. Chipeta on the food crisis in Eastern Africa
 flecheNumber of hungry people rises to 963 million
 flecheLe rôle de l’Afrique dans la réduction des gaz à effet de serre
 flecheDiouf appeals for new world agricultural order
 flecheFAO Chief appeals to Obama to help end world hunger
 flecheFinancial crash could deepen food crisis - protectionism, less aid not a solution.
 flecheWorld Food Day stresses climate change and bioenergy effects on poor
 flecheReviewing biofuel policies and subsidies - Annual report weighs opportunities and risks of biofuels
 flecheIndigenous peoples threatened by climate change
 flecheNew global soil database
 flecheClimate change will have strong impact on fisheries
 flecheLand degradation on the rise: one fourth of the world’s population affected, says new study

 flecheSichuan quake: $6bn damage to agriculture
 flecheFood Summit calls for more investment in agriculture - and final declaration
 flecheThe world only needs 30 billion dollars a year to eradicate the scourge of hunger
 flecheHigh food prices: supporting the poor and re-launching agriculture - June Summit on food security offers historic chance to address world food challenges
 flecheFood prices remain high despite higher output
 flecheBiodiversity to curb world's food insecurity
 flecheDiouf: world must seize chance to boost agriculture
 flecheLarge-scale biofuel production may increase marginalization of women


 flecheA major boost to preparations for the FAO Summit on food security: Brazilian President Lula confirms his presence
 flecheHigh-Level Conference on World Food Security: "the Challenges of Climate Change and Bioenergy" (3-5 June 2008, FAO Headquarters - Rome)
 flechePoorest countries’ cereal bill continues to soar, governments try to limit impact
 flecheEBRD-FAO report: Fighting food inflation
 flecheUsing oil export revenues to boost public investment in agriculture
 flecheOpening of seed vault in Norway
 flecheSignificant increase in world cereal production forecast for 2008, but prices remain high
 flecheRome UN Agencies urge immediate climate action to avert hunger
 flecheCall for more strategic approach to mountain development
 flecheConverting wood waste into pellets to reduce greenhouse gases
 flecheLaunch of an interactive web-based platform in support of agriculture and rural development
 flecheHarnessing the Web to speed rural development
 flecheDramatic changes in global meat production could increase risk of diseases


 fleche The state of the world’s animal genetic ressources for food and agriculture
 flecheGlobal plan of action for animal genetic resources adopted
 flecheClimate change likely to increase risk of hunger
 flecheReport "OECD-FAO Agricultural Outlook 2007-2016"
 flecheGrowing bio-fuel demand underpinning higher agriculture prices
 flechePoverty in fishing communities poses serious risks
 flecheThe State of Agricultural Commodity Markets 2006
 flecheNew trade rules expected to benefit some developing countries
 flecheAppropriate trade policy reform can lead to poverty reduction
 flecheFAO urges action to cope with increasing water scarcity
 flecheFAO confident UK authorities can handle bird flu outbreak
 flecheFAO urges food aid reform
 flecheEradicating world hunger: taking stock ten years after the World Food Summit
 flecheAgricultural heritage: legacy from the past, passport for the future
(Forum highlights importance of family agriculture for sustainable development)

 flecheDeforestation causes global warming
 flecheCaucasus, Balkans at high risk for deadly H5N1 virus
 flecheNew focus needed for Doha Round

 flecheWorld Congress on Communication for Development
 flecheForests and climate change
 flecheScience and global livestock
 flecheInternational rural development conference in Porto Alegre
 flecheEscalating bird flu crisis jeopardizes global poultry trade prospects
 flecheFAO and the challenge of the Millennium Development Goals : The road ahead
 flecheNew FAO report on agricultural trade and poverty
 flecheThe State of Food Insecurity in the World 2005
 flecheHunger slows progress towards Millennium Development Goals
 flecheThe digital divide continues to hinder development in rural areas
 flecheGlobal influenza meeting sets key action steps

 flecheNew global agricultural census under way
 flecheAfricans meet to improve food safety on the continent
 flecheMalawi facing serious food crisis
 flecheAgriculture and intercultural dialogue
 flecheFunding shortfall could worsen food crisis in Niger
 flecheThe Kyoto process: an additional opportunity for the poorest countries?
 flecheWest African food crisis looming
 flecheJoining forces to halve hunger
 flecheEducation for rural people, a crucial step towards the Millennium Goals
 flecheClimate change could increase the number of hungry people
 flecheArmed conflicts leading cause of world hunger emergencies
 flecheSuccess stories in forest management
 flecheAfghanistan: 14 000 grain silos to be distributed to farmers
 flecheWorsening food situation in parts of the Sahel
 fleche23 sub-Saharan African countries need food assistance
 flecheBenefits and risks of globalized livestock markets
 flecheL'élevage à l'heure de la mondialisation
 flecheDiouf, Jacques
 flecheFAO assessing damage in countries devastated by tsunamis in South Asia
 flecheEuropean Commission and FAO extend food security programme
 flecheHunger costs millions of lives and billions of dollars - FAO hunger report
 flecheFAO Council adopts Right to Food Guidelines
 flecheFAO calls for $60 million for urgent agricultural relief in 14 emergencies worldwide
 flecheInvolving the rural poor in development programmes
 flecheAgricultural database
 flecheThe future of agriculture depends on biodiversity
 flecheSustainable development in mountain regions: the path ahead
 flecheWealth and poverty continue to coexist in Europe - Diouf
 flecheWealth and poverty continue to coexist in Europe - Diouf
 flecheThe challenge of sustainable mountain development
 flecheTreaty on biodiversity to become law
 flecheUnited Nations agencies applaud new political focus on hunger and rural poverty
 flecheBSE controls in many countries are still not sufficient
 flecheSouth-South Cooperation: creating alliances to fight hunger
 flecheFAO reports a setback in the war against hunger
 flecheNorth Korea urgently needs food aid
 flecheWorking together for an International Alliance against Hunger
 flecheOnline scientific information on food and agriculture for poorest countries
 fleche$6 million project for one of the poorest regions in Afghanistan
 flecheFood crisis in parts of Ethiopia remains critical
 flecheSustainable forest management: tangible achievements needed
 flecheSeeds and tools for nearly 2 million farmers in Angola
 flecheFAO sees no alternative to multilateral trade talks
 flecheLa FAO réclame davantage d'aide alimentaire pour plusieurs pays d'Afrique sub-saharienne
 flecheWorld agriculture towards 2030 - Final study published
 flecheDe la nourriture pour penser : promouvoir l'éducation pour les populations rurales
 flecheWorld agriculture: towards 2015/2030
13
SEARCH
Keywords   go
in 
the articles