Ref. :  000018056
Date :  2005-04-08
Language :  English
Home Page / The whole website
fr / es / de / po / en

How does the European Commission deal with ethical issues within its Framework Programme for Research and Development

Author :  Union européenne

Janez Potočnik, European Commissioner for Science and Research, has indicated that the European Commission proposes to continue the current strict ethical framework within the future research programme. This note sets this framework out in detail, and provides some information about research carried out under the current research programme.

What does the proposal for a Seventh Framework Programme for Research says about ethical issues?

In the proposal for a decision on FP7, the following recital and article are included with regard to the respect of fundamental ethical principles.
Recital 25: Research activities supported by this Framework Programme should respect fundamental ethical principles, including those reflected in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. The opinions of the European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies are and will be taken into account.
Article 6: All the research activities carried out under the Seventh Framework Programme shall be carried out in compliance with fundamental ethical principles.
The Commission’s proposal will now pass to the Council and European Parliament for decision.

What is the situation regarding human embryos and embryonic stem cells within the Sixth Framework Programme?

The current Sixth Framework Programme’s specific programme on “Integrating and Strengthening the European Research Area”, decided by Council in agreement with Parliament, explicitly forbids EU funding for research that involves human reproductive cloning, the creation of human embryos for research (often referred to as therapeutic cloning) and research that would change the genetic heritage.

The European Group on Ethics has delivered an opinion on ethical questions in EU research programmes and another opinion on EU funding for stem cell research.
The Sixth Framework Programme does allow EU funding of projects involving the derivation and use of human embryonic stem cells (HESC) derived from supernumerary embryos (i.e. embryos left over from in-vitro fertilisation that are most often destined to be disposed off and for which parents give an explicit agreement that they can be used for research purposes). Such projects are examined on a case by case basis.

What is the procedure for the case-by-case examination of projects?

EU research programmes never fund in a Member State under any circumstances anything that is forbidden in that particular Member State.
Priority is given in all circumstances to research on adult stem cells (i.e. derived from adults or umbilical cord blood), which pose no ethical problems.

All proposals received first undergo a very thorough scientific evaluation by independent experts.
Those proposals that pass the scientific evaluation are submitted to a stringent ethical review by a pluralist team of ethical experts. Furthermore, each project should get a favourable opinion from a local or national ethics committee from each country where HESC research will be carried out. In other terms, each project with a component of HESC research funded at the EU level will be scrutinised by at least two ethical reviews (one at national level and one at EU level), but it can be more if HESC is expected to be performed in more than one country.

As long as there is no decision on ethical criteria for EU funding of human embryonic stem cell research, the Commission has committed itself not to fund a project that involves the derivation of stem cells from human supernumerary embryos (i.e. implying the destruction of the supernumerary embryo in question), but only to fund projects involving HESC that were derived outside the scope of the EU-funded project in question.

Those proposals that pass the scientific evaluation and the ethical review are submitted for opinion to Member States, meeting as a regulatory committee. No project is funded that does not receive a favourable opinion from that Committee.

What EU funding is available for stem cell research?

There is no element of the programme that directly calls for proposals on stem cell research. All research on stem cells, whether adult or embryonic, takes place within projects tackling a specific health issue, with a component of research using stem cells.

At this stage, as a result of the first call for proposals under the “health” priority of FP6, the Commission is currently funding 25 projects involving component of stem cell research. These mainly concern adult stem cells. Only two projects involve a component of human embryonic stem cell research; these projects have both received a favourable opinion from the Member States (through the regulatory committee). The funding for these two projects amounts to about €500,000, less than 0.1% of the EU research money available for health research in the first call for proposals, and about 0.002% of the Sixth Framework Programme budget

Following the second call for proposals under the health priority, a proposal involving the use of existing HESC lines (addressing diabetes, called BetaCellTherapy) has been positively reviewed, both scientifically and ethically, and has just received a favourable opinion from the regulatory committee of Member States.

In the context of the decision-making process on FP6, the Commission has committed itself to supporting the set up of a European registry of HESC lines, similar to the NIH registry in the USA. Support for such a registry, which would allow an ethical tracking of existing HESC lines in Europe and their optimal use, has been the subject of the second and third calls for proposals under FP6. In both cases, the proposals received were found by the evaluators to be of insufficient quality to be funded. Because the Commission attaches great importance to this subject, it will be reopened for proposals in the 4th call for proposals in the course of 2005.

Which Member States allow research using human embryonic stem cells?

Belgium, UK and Sweden allow research using therapeutic cloning, which is expressly forbidden from receiving EU research programme funding.

Denmark, Finland, France, Greece, Spain, Netherlands have regulations allowing the derivation of new human embryonic stem cells from supernumerary IVF embryos.
Estonia, Hungary, Latvia and Slovenia have no regulations, but allow some research on supernumerary IVF embryos.
Germany and Italy have regulations which restrict human embryonic stem cell research. These regulations mean that scientists in these countries cannot derive new human embryonic stem cells, but can import them. In Germany, these cells have to have been derived before 1 January 2002.
Austria, Ireland, Lithuania and Poland have legislation prohibiting human embryonic stem cell research.

What is the worldwide situation?

In the US, federal funds are restricted to funding research on existing human embryonic stem cells derived before 9 August 2001. There are no restrictions for industrial, private or state funds, though some states are currently reviewing their funding rules.
China, India, Israel, Singapore and South Korea currently allow therapeutic cloning.
Australia, Brazil, Canada, Japan, Switzerland and Taiwan have regulations allowing the derivation of human embryonic stem cells from supernumerary IVF embryos. The Swiss rules were approved by a public referendum in November 2004.

Rate this content
Average of 56 ratings 
Rating 2.38 / 4 MoyenMoyenMoyenMoyen
Same author:
 flecheMinimum wages in the EU in January 2007
 flecheThe Court of First Instance annuls the decision authorising the creation of Sony BMG
 flecheCommission proposes practical improvements to the way the European GMO legislative framework is implemented
 flecheEconomic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) with ACP countries
 flecheBarcelona Declaration and Euro-Mediterranean partnership
 flecheEU Trade Commissioner Peter Mandelson to meet Malinese President Toumani Toure; will recall EU Doha commitments on cotton trade
 flecheCommission provides an additional €4 M to victims of tropical storm Stan in El Salvador and Guatemala
 flecheHumanitarian aid: Commission allocates € 6 million for victims of the conflict in Nepal and for Bhutanese refugees
 flecheUnemployment rates of the total population by level of education (EU 25)
 flecheEU25 : Convergence and Competitiveness Objectives 2007-2013 (draft)
 flecheLa recherche à pas de géant
 fleche Un avenir européen pour le Kosovo
 flecheMobiliser les cerveaux européens: permettre aux universités de contribuer pleinement à la stratégie de Lisbonne
 flecheL'Institut universitaire européen de Florence propose un nouveau programme postdoctoral en sciences sociales
 flecheZimbabwe: Commission allocates €15 million in humanitarian aid to vulnerable groups
 flecheWhat is a researcher? European Commission defines roles and responsibilities
 flecheAvian Influenza: Commission proposes updated measures aimed at preventing epidemics
 flecheEuropeans want policy makers to consider the environment as important as economic and social policies
 flecheStatement by the President of the European Commission, José Manuel Barroso, to mark the first anniversary of enlargement, 1 May 2005
 flecheDirective du Parlement Européen et du Conseil relative aux services dans le marché intérieur
 flecheInformation note of the European Court of Auditors on Special Report No 10/2004 concerning the audit of Devolution of EC external aid management to the Commission Delegations [1]
 flecheLessons from Spain: more focus on young voters needed and people should be informed to become convinced. Results of a post-referendum Eurobarometer in Spain
 flecheFree movement of goods: too many infringements are hampering economic growth
 flechePosting of workers: the Commission asks Greece and the Netherlands to end unjustified restrictions
 flecheEU research maximises regional dynamics, boosts competitiveness for EU SMEs
 flecheEuropean Commission welcomes G8 commitment to put Africa and Development high on its agenda
 flecheCustoms: Commission proposes strategy for simplified rules of origin
 flecheEurope's population is getting older. How will this affect us and what should we do about it?
 flecheLisbon strategy can make a significant contribution to growth, a Commission report shows
 flecheTreaty establishing a Constitution for Europe
 flecheCompetitiveness Council backs Commission “partnership for growth and jobs”
 flecheGender Mainstreaming in EU policies
 flecheEuropean Neighbourhood Policy: the next steps
 flecheDoha Round: EU Commissioners Mandelson and Fischer Boel travel to Kenya for multilateral trade talks
 flecheEuropean research infrastructures: a means to boost knowledge and fuel growth
 flecheMergers: Commission approves acquisition of Shell Gas by Repsol Butano
 flecheConférence sur la politique européenne de développement
 flecheCommission adopts favourable opinion on the accession of Bulgaria and Romania
 flecheEuropean researchers based in the US want more contact with Europe
 flecheThe Commission adopts a new Drugs Action Plan for 2005-2008
 flecheLes chercheurs européens établis aux États-Unis veulent un renforcement des contacts avec l’Europe
 flecheA reinforced transatlantic dialogue will be beneficial to the rest of the world
 flecheEuropean Commission accelerates preferential trade measures to benefit tsunami-hit countries
 flecheEU Trade Commissioner proposes trade measures to complement G8 push on debt, aid and development
 flecheEU launches new export help service for developing countries
 flecheSpecial ASEAN Summit
 flecheCommission sharpens fight against cross-border crime in the EU
 flecheEurobarometer on Constitution: a positive attitude, but a lack of information
 flecheLatest European regional statistics confirm Commission’s proposal on Structural Funds for 2007-2013
 flecheSurvey shows European public is largely at ease with euro three years after adoption
 flecheDeclaration by the Presidency on behalf of the European Union on Sudan – Signing of the comprehensive peace agreement on 9 January 2005 in Nairobi
 fleche “Mental illness is Europe’s unseen killer” says Markos Kyprianou
 flecheFrance: Commission pursues legal action for failures to respect six environment rulings of the European Court of Justice
 flecheNovember 2004: Euro-zone and EU25 unemployment stable at 8.9%
 flecheCommission’s report indicates that governments should do more to implement energy market opening measures
 flecheOctober 2004: Euro-zone external trade surplus 5.5 bn euro
 flecheBrussels European Council: Presidency conclusions
 flecheEIB AND Inter-American Development Bank sign memorandum of understanding
 flecheCommission launches public consultation on future programme for active citizenship
 flecheProtecting Europe from epidemics: Director named for new EU health agency
 fleche"EU and Turkey on the threshold of a new phase"
 flecheGreat Lakes Region - Humanitarian Situation
 flecheEurobarometer: marked improvement in perception of the European Union and what it does
 flecheBarcelona hosts the Festival of European Cinema, with the support of the MEDIA programme
 flecheEU equips parents with internet safety tools
 flecheEuropean Neighbourhood Policy: the first Action Plans
 flecheNature protection: Commission establishes largest ever list of protected areas in the EU
 flecheEU - China Summit : China now second trade partner of EU25
 flecheUN conference on climate change: EU set to keep momentum in the global fight against climate change
 flecheCommission consults public on action plan to reduce air pollution
 flecheFull text of the Constitution
 flecheEuropean Constitution : Procedures planned for the ratification
 flecheThe European Union and Emerging World Orders: Perceptions and Strategies - speech of Ján Figel, Commissioner for Education, Training, Culture and Multilingualism
 flecheChemical Pollution: EU ratifies Stockholm POP Convention
 flecheCitizens make increasing use of the European Ombudsman
 flecheUNESCO negotiations on cultural diversity: the Commission obtains a mandate from the Council
 flecheEU strategy to enforce Intellectual Property Rights in third countries - facts and figures
 flecheEuropean Council - Conclusions
 flecheReport from the Commission to the Spring European Council: Delivering Lisbon - reforms for the enlarged Union
 flecheEU Presidency Statement - Migration issues
 flecheAccess to medicines: Commission proposes to allow export of generic medicines to poor countries
 flecheFourth Report on Citizenship of the Union
 flecheQuestions & Answers: The entry into force of the Kyoto Protocol
 flecheThe European Anthem
 flecheDeveloping countries: facts and figures on the new EU scheme of trade preferences for 2006-2008
 flecheEU-ACP: EU, Commonwealth and Francophonie join hands in supporting ACP trade policy makers
 flecheYoung people and drugs: changing attitudes in the Member States since 2002
 fleche"The European Ombudsman: Could he help you?" : now available in 21 languages
 flecheWTO-Vietnam: EU and Vietnam conclude bilateral deal for Vietnam's accession to WTO
 flecheUS-Boeing: EU takes US to the WTO over subsidies granted to Boeing
 flecheASEM 5 Summit in Hanoi, Vietnam, 7-9th October 2004
 flecheEU-Mercosur: EU presents its completed offer to Mercosur in on-going trade talks
 flecheLIFE+: Commission proposes new streamlined funding programme for the environment
 flecheEU-Mercosur: EU presents its completed offer to Mercosur in on-going trade talks
 flecheRomano Prodi, President of the European Commission, Conference on EMU and economic governance - Closing address
 flecheRecommandation from the Commission to the Council to authorise the Commission to participate, on behalf of the Community, in the
negotiations within UNESCO on the convention on the protection of the diversity of cultural contents and artistic expressions.

 flecheEU can and must boost employment with the right policies
 flecheFor a more effective involvement of civil society in world trade talks
 flecheErasmus Mundus: 82 European universities launch programme
 flecheTrade and Development: success stories in EU trade-related assistance
 flecheGlobal efforts for the environment: Commission and UNEP to reinforce co-operation
 flecheCommission moves smartly to launch European Mobility Week
 flecheCommission launches stakeholder consultation on future climate change policy
 flecheJoining forces to alleviate poverty and hunger in developing countries
 flecheLabour Force Survey – 2003. Employment rate in the EU25 in 2003
 flecheEU-Pacific Trade: facts and figures
 flecheEU-ASEAN: Trade and Investment initiative makes headway
 flecheThe European Commission confirms the need for a Community regulatory framework for nuclear safety and radioactive waste management
 fleche'For Diversity. Against Discrimination' truck tour to help the drive against discrimination in the EU
 flecheUS Byrd Amendment – WTO says eight WTO Members may retaliate against the US – Joint Press statement by Brazil, Canada, Chile, the EU, India, Japan, Korea, and Mexico
 flecheEuropean demography in 2003 : EU25 population up by 0.4% to reach 456 million. One in 14 people in world live in the EU25

 flecheDarfur crisis: Commission releases a further 20 million euros in humanitarian aid
 flecheThe "Europass Training"
 flecheImplementation of EU environmental law: survey highlights serious shortcomings
 flecheLife expectancy in the member states of the European Union
 flecheEnlargement Day Celebrations - 25 Members of the EU at Farmleigh,Dublin
 flecheFurther European Union Support for the Presidential Elections in Afghanistan
 flecheSigning the Nice Treaty (February 26, 2001)
 flecheSolana, Javier
 fleche"Television without Frontiers"
 flecheLa politique de recherche et l'espace dans le Traité constitutionnel
 flecheWTO: EU committed to progress in WTO negotiations
 flecheEU INSPIREs better geographical info
 flecheFourth Euromed Trade Ministerial:
towards an integrated Euro-Mediterranean market

 flecheEmployment and poverty reduction in developing countries
 flecheCommission strengthens cohesion policy in the enlarged European Union
 flecheThe Commission proposes new Education, MEDIA, Culture and Youth programmes for 2007-2013
 flecheSudan/Chad: Commission earmarks further 18 million euros for victims of Darfur crisis
 fleche"1000 discussions for Europe" on the new Constitution
 flecheProtection de la couche d'ozone : la Commission intente une action contre neuf États membres
 flecheEU action against HIV/AIDS
 flecheDeveloping countries: Commission unveils system of trade preferences for next ten years - simple, transparent and objective
 flecheLe Prix Prince des Asturies « Coopération internationale » attribué au programme Erasmus
 flecheEU-Africa Cotton Forum: Pascal Lamy proposes a joint strategy for African countries
 flecheHealth in developing countries - Commission and World Health Organization join forces to deliver on development goals

 flecheRoadmap for EU-U.S. Regulatory Cooperation and Transparency
 flecheMobility of researchers: the EU proposes new prospects and opportunities
 flecheGlobalisation and Trade: How to make sure there is space for development?
 flecheDeclaration by the Presidency on behalf of the European Union on the situation in Darfur, western Sudan
 flecheEU EPICA research project: solving the climate change puzzle?
 flecheMap showing the use of the euro
 flecheUnião Européia
 flecheBalkans occidentaux: lancement des premiers partenariats européens

 flecheEU citizens in favour of a common asylum and immigration policy
 flecheEU Strategy Against Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction
 flecheBrussels European Council: PRESIDENCY CONCLUSIONS
 flecheSeptember 2003 Euro-zone unemployment stable at 8.8%
 flecheEU-ACPs: opening of trade negotiations with West and Central Africa
 flecheDraft Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe
 flecheThe full text of the draft Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe
 flecheEuropean Commission regrets US decision to file WTO case on GMOs as misguided and unnecessary
 flecheAthens Declaration
 flechePremier Forum des Parlementaires Africains pour le Nouveau Partenariat pour l'Afrique (NEPAD)
 flecheL' "Amendement Byrd" en infraction avec les règles de l'OMC
 flecheEuropean Union launches coalition of like-minded states to deliver World Summit renewable energy goals
Keywords   go
Translate this page Traduire par Google Translate

Share on Facebook
Partager sur Twitter
Share on Google+Google + Share on LinkedInLinkedIn
Partager sur MessengerMessenger Partager sur BloggerBlogger
Other items
where is published this article: